I’ve had great luck with the Hankook ATM RF10. I’m on my third set. They wear great, are quiet, and are very good in winter conditions. Pretty cheap too. Not very exciting but a solid all terrain tire.
You can get a Ridge Grappler in XL for a little less than the BFG and it should have a stronger sidewall than you are currently running. I'm getting the same size Falken AT3W SL for my WK2 but I don't have any issues with punctures.